The Weight of the World

I am a part, albeit small, of the teacher shortage crisis.

One Thursday, late in my teaching career, life’s routine responsibilities overwhelmed me, threatening to crush my spirit. In the morning, I knew a stack of essays awaited me on my desk, each one representing hours of painstaking grading and feedback. The teachers’ lounge printer churned out even more lesson plan materials, adding to the consistent growth of my paperwork mountain.

Entering my crowded classroom, I faced a sea of expectant faces, each seeking guidance and inspiration from me. Speaking up in this noisy room, I felt quite overwhelmed by all the expectations and demands on me. Earlier that year, feeling desperate, I sought support from my teacher’s union, seeking solace and solidarity among fellow educators. I poured my heart into that letter, explaining the challenges I faced and how they affected my well-being. With every word, I hoped someone would hear and respond appropriately to my cries for help. Unfortunately, instead I received only solace and empty platitudes.

My students setup their laptops to take the exam mandated by my district for all teachers of English. 15 minutes later, half the class couldn’t take the exam because of IT compatibility issues, issues that could have easily been foreseen had the implementation of the new English Learning Platform not been rushed. I had to print paper tests since the exam had begun, and it seemed like a straightforward solution. It was completely reasonable to print the tests out then and there while someone watched my class. But, as usual, our equipment had issues. The tests came out unstapled and out of order due to printer jams. When I returned to my classroom, I found that the software had caught many of my students cheating. Frustrated, I approached my department head. They subsequently put the responsibility of the students’ decision to cheat on my shoulders and proceeded to subtly question my competence as an educator. Thursday felt like a perfect storm of chaos and cruelty, especially after all my hard work.

I mention this day because it marked my final day as an official employee at that school. I did not return and I never regretted it; not even for a single second.

The Teacher Shortage Crisis: A Catalyst for Change

Today, the shortage of qualified teachers is causing widespread repercussions, affecting schools, students, and communities across the nation. The crisis arises from a mix of factors: demographic changes, shifts in the workforce, and systemic issues in education. Throughout the U.S., schools grapple with a shortage of educators, especially in crucial subjects like math, science, and special education. Experienced teachers are exiting the profession or retiring prematurely and new teachers are being rushed in and spit out.

Besides recruitment and retention challenges, the teacher shortage crisis burdens the educators who stay in the profession. Large class sizes, fewer support staff, and limited resources strain teachers’ capacity to offer quality instruction and support to students. This not only affects academic outcomes but also contributes to high levels of stress and burnout among educators.

What is most important is that our nation’s youth grow up well-rounded and successful. Equally so, they must be grounded emotionally, physically, and spiritually as much as possible. Unfortunately, this is not happening as a direct result of their public education.

The Impact of the Shortage on Students

Obviously, the harm caused by the teacher shortage crisis extends to students as well. First and foremost, the teacher shortage crisis exacerbates existing disparities in educational opportunity and outcomes, particularly for marginalized and underserved communities. Teacher shortages disproportionately affect schools serving low-income students and students of color. If this doesn’t change, the systemic inequities will continue for years, decades, or even centuries.

And across the board, schools often overlook the needs of their educators, despite educators’ direct interactions with students on a daily basis. Overworked, stressed, and unsupported teachers will inevitably leave behind a negative impact on the learning environment and well-being of students.

Students can sense an overwhelmed or stressed teacher. This tension, if persistent enough, can create an anxious atmosphere in the classroom, hindering students’ ability to focus, engage, and learn effectively. In some cases, students may internalize their teachers’ stress and exhibit behavioral issues or emotional distress as a result.

When schools neglect teachers’ well-being, it sends a harmful message to students about the importance of education. Ignoring educators’ needs undermines schools’ capacity to create a safe, nurturing, and supportive learning environment for everyone. Note that managing a safe environment is a major expectation on most educator evaluations.

In summary, the teacher shortage aids in persistent racism in our country’s student body. The shortage further widens the achievement gap between the “have” students and the “have-nots” students. Additionally, as a direct result from lack of adequate faculty support, students are subject to unsafe learning environments and face undeserved exposure to overwhelming stress.

Teacher Shortage = More Mid-Year Departures

One of the most distressing consequences of the teacher shortage crisis is the prevalence of educators leaving their positions mid-year. For all students, but especially those in underserved communities, teacher departures can be highly disruptive. Students truly lose trusted mentors and role-models. Students frequently build connections with teachers, turning to them for guidance, encouragement, and safety.

Hence, when a teacher departs suddenly, students may feel abandoned, confused, and anxious, disrupting both their learning and emotional stability. Moreover, the loss of continuity in instruction can hinder students’ academic progress and hyperbolize existing achievement gaps even more.

Teachers often resort to leaving mid-year due to untenable working conditions, overwhelming stress, or personal circumstances. Even with their utmost efforts to support students, educators likely feel guilt and sadness when leaving their classrooms behind.

Since the teacher shortage started, there has been an overwhelming uptick in mid-year departures. In North Carolina, for instance, an estimated 2% increase of mid-year departures from 2021-2022 (Barnum).

Identifying the Root Causes of the Shortage Crisis

To understand the teacher shortage crisis, it’s essential to identify and understand its root causes. This is really not challenging due to decades of neglect and systemic failures that have eroded support for educators.

One of the primary contributors to the crisis is the lack of administrative support within schools. Educators often struggle with bureaucratic hurdles, conflicting mandates, and limited resources, diverting their attention from teaching and learning. Administrative burdens like excessive paperwork, compliance requirements, and standardized testing mandates worsen teacher workload, leading to high burnout rates.

Teaching has become less attractive due to low pay, limited career advancement, and difficult working conditions. Educators receive stagnant wages, insufficient benefits, and unstable employment contracts, hindering recruitment and retention of qualified professionals. Furthermore, job demands such as long hours, heavy workloads, and minimal support, affect teachers’ physical and mental health. This harsh reality only adds to abhorrent attrition rates.

Systemic inequities worsen challenges for educators, particularly in low-income communities and schools serving students of color. These schools often lack resources and support, leading to higher turnover rates among teachers and administrators.

Another factor contributing to the teacher shortage crisis is the erosion of teacher autonomy and professionalism. Educators often feel disempowered and undervalued in a system that prioritizes standardized testing, compliance, and top-down mandates over teacher autonomy. The loss of professional autonomy hurts teacher morale and stifles innovation in the classroom, affecting student learning.

Additionally, large class sizes and forced coteaching in overpopulated cities nearly doubles a teachers’ workload for the same pay as they would get elsewhere. The love of students can only soothe an educator for so long.

A shortage of bilingual educators and illogical organization make teaching Multilingual Language Learners (MLL’s) particularly difficult. They are scattered across mainstream classes for equity reasons with complete randomness and/or disregard as to their proficiency in competitive English. Furthermore, there is nobody to aid the mainstream teacher with this impossible burden. This puts the excessive workload on teachers, for equity reasons, without even achieving quality results. We have students passing grades without even understanding what the objectives they were supposed to meet even mean!

Addressing the root causes of the teacher shortage crisis requires a comprehensive and systemic approach. This approach must be bold in tackling structural inequities, student to teacher ratios, student learning, policy failures, and organizational hierarchies that have perpetuated the status quo. As we seek to revampify education, we must ensure that we are retaining high quality educators who love their profession. Achieving this requires fair compensation, clear communication, and reasonable deadlines. Teachers need adequate time for tasks within their workday and additional support educators in multilingual classrooms to assist students of varying proficiency levels. Additionally, creating a psychologically safe environment through collaboration and alleviating high stress is also crucial.

Supporting Evidence

Numerous studies and surveys underscore the pervasive stress and burnout among teachers. These findings emphasize the need for collaboration among policymakers, school boards, and educators to improve mental health and job satisfaction. For example, a national survey by RAND Corporation revealed concerning trends in teacher well-being (Steiner and Woo). One in four teachers considered leaving their jobs, with higher stress and depression rates than the general population.

Conclusion

The teacher shortage crisis is a complex and multifaceted issue that requires a coordinated and comprehensive response from all stakeholders. As we revampify education, we will continue to Identify root issues in education, innovate systemic solutions to those problems, all while we publicly value educators and students through respectful policy-change and interactions. The hope is that we foster an equitable and supportive education system.

Please be sure to:

• Subscribe to my YouTube Channel
• Add and follow me on Facebook
• Follow me on Twitter
• Follow me on Instagram
• Subscribe to my Blog
• Leave a comment below with any questions and concerns and I will gladly get back to you